We still don’t know if Ace Frehley will be part of the upcoming KISS farewell tour, but the guitarist did join the band on their eigth annual KISS Kruise, which set sail on Wednesday.

Frehley and ex-KISS guitarist Bruce Kulick both joined the band on stage for an acoustic set on the cruise’s first night.

Paul Stanley joking called it a “coincidence” that Frehley and Kulick “just happened” to be on the same ship.

The appearance gives some hope to fans who want Frehley to be part of KISS’s “End Of The Road” tour, which launches early next year.